I have been running creatine monohydrate for eight months and the honest summary is that the effect is smaller than the internet suggests and real.
I would rather have a narrow conclusion and be right than a broad one and be interesting.
There is a serious question about whether the studied form matches what is sold, and nobody in a thread can answer it.
My rule now: if a claim cannot survive being written down with the numbers attached, it is marketing.
Loose evidence is not the same as no evidence and people overcorrect in both directions.
Would like a narrow answer rather than an enthusiastic one.
Loose evidence is not nothing, but a washout either side is the only reason to trust your own take.
Read the methods section. It is the only part that says whether the conclusion is allowed to exist.
Underdosing and tolerance are indistinguishable from the inside, and everyone picks the flattering explanation. Tolerance was my main issue with creatine monohydrate too.
This is the kind of post the forum exists for. Same for me with creatine monohydrate, unfortunately.