Trying to separate three different claims about collagen peptides: that it is the right molecule, that it is the right dose, and that it does something useful.
Tolerance and underdosing look identical from the inside, which is why the answer is usually a blood test and not more forums.
I would rather have a narrow conclusion and be right than a broad one and be interesting.
Most of the popular protocols are borrowed from clinical populations and applied to healthy people without comment.
The comparison group matters more than the compound when the outcome is something as fuzzy as focus.
How do you separate the compound effect from the routine around it?
I would take the narrow conclusion. Broad ones are more interesting and less true.
Loose evidence is not nothing, but a washout either side is the only reason to trust your own take. Not on collagen peptides but the pattern is familiar.
How long before you can reasonably say something is or is not doing anything?
Loose evidence and no evidence are different, and people overcorrect in both directions.