I have been running rhodiola rosea for five years and the honest summary is that the effect is smaller than the internet suggests and real.
Tolerance and underdosing look identical from the inside, which is why the answer is usually a blood test and not more forums.
Most of the popular protocols are borrowed from clinical populations and applied to healthy people without comment.
What the botanical class does pharmacologically does not require the subjective effect to be large to be real.
The effect size I actually noticed is roughly a third of what the write-ups imply, and it took five years to be sure.
Standardisation matters more than dose with botanicals, and most products say nothing about it.
How do you separate the compound effect from the routine around it?
Nobody has ever been talked out of a stack by a stranger on the internet.