Trying to separate three different claims about memantine: that it is the right molecule, that it is the right dose, and that it does something useful.
If you need three other compounds to notice the first one, you have not tested the first one.
Sample size, blinding, and who paid for it. Those three questions kill most of the confidence in most of these threads.
What surprised me is how much of the perceived benefit was routine and attention rather than pharmacology.
There is a serious question about whether the studied form matches what is sold, and nobody in a thread can answer it.
What would change your mind about this?
Most of what is called evidence here is one person, one vial, one month. Two months in on memantine and it lines up.
Underdosing and tolerance are indistinguishable from the inside, and everyone picks the flattering explanation.
How long before you can reasonably say something is or is not doing anything?