I have been running L-theanine for a year and the honest summary is that the effect is smaller than the internet suggests and real.
Loose evidence is not the same as no evidence and people overcorrect in both directions.
I would rather have a narrow conclusion and be right than a broad one and be interesting.
What the amino acid class does pharmacologically does not require the subjective effect to be large to be real.
The effect size I actually noticed is roughly a third of what the write-ups imply, and it took a year to be sure.
Would like a narrow answer rather than an enthusiastic one.
How long before you can reasonably say something is or is not doing anything?
Baseline first. Currently on L-theanine myself.
An inconclusive account is useful if it stops the next person mistaking a story for a controlled comparison.