I have been running ashwagandha for three years and the honest summary is that the effect is smaller than the internet suggests and real.
Forum consensus and published consensus diverged here about five years ago and never reconverged.
What the botanical class does pharmacologically does not require the subjective effect to be large to be real.
Standardisation matters more than dose with botanicals, and most products say nothing about it.
Happy to be corrected on any of the above.
Three questions kill most of the confidence in a thread like this: sample size, blinding, who paid.
Three questions kill most of the confidence in a thread like this: sample size, blinding, who paid.
Baseline first. Same for me with ashwagandha, unfortunately.
A plausible mechanism is not an outcome, and this class is the textbook example.
Loose evidence and no evidence are different, and people overcorrect in both directions.