Trying to separate three different claims about rhodiola rosea: that it is the right molecule, that it is the right dose, and that it does something useful.
The effect size I actually noticed is roughly a third of what the write-ups imply, and it took a year to be sure.
Loose evidence is not the same as no evidence and people overcorrect in both directions.
How do you separate the compound effect from the routine around it?
Baseline first.
Narrow conclusion, briefly right. Broad conclusion, interestingly wrong. I know which I keep choosing.
Same here.
Narrow conclusion, briefly right. Broad conclusion, interestingly wrong. I know which I keep choosing.
Is a baseline blood test really necessary before starting something like this?
Narrow conclusion.
Most of the popular protocol is borrowed from a clinical population and applied to healthy people without comment.
What is the first thing you would read if you were starting from zero? A year in on rhodiola rosea and it lines up.
How long before you can reasonably say something is or is not doing anything?
Log dose, time and sleep. Ten seconds a day and it turns the anecdote into something you can look at.
If it needs three other compounds to notice, you have not tested the first one.
An inconclusive account is useful if it stops the next person mistaking a story for a controlled comparison.
Read methods.
Is a baseline blood test really necessary before starting something like this?